Social Media ROI not always about the dollars
I’ve been thinking about social media ROI for a while. I still haven’t figured it out. If you asked, I couldn’t give you a great recommendation on the best metrics to use to prove ROI for your business. Every brand wants to make a buck or two from their social media efforts, but I don’t think that is where the real value resides.
Our social media mission
When we entered into social media at Publix, our CEO wanted two things:
- any social media efforts we offered must be an extension of our retail store experience, where we strive to offer a premier shopping experience for each customer.
- we needed to differentiate the social media experience for our customers from those offered by our competition.
While we still have work to do, I think we have accomplished both those goals. According to all the metrics we can find, we have a higher level of engagement with our Facebook fans than any of our retail competitors. Our growth has been stellar, and our own fans have commented many times that they can’t believe how often and how quickly we respond to questions and customer concerns on Facebook. I can’t share numbers, but our push marketing works too.
We accomplished this by one simple method.
We talk to our customers. The benefit of that is that our customers talk back to us. We are engaging in conversation about our products, new store locations, how to save money shopping, and even suggestions on how to improve the shopping experience, coming from people who want to engage with our brand. How awesome is that?
The ROI lies in the value added communication
We’re not able to measure customer conversions or how many sale are generated by a Facebook post. We create our social ROI by offering the same kind of service to our customers on Facebook as they receive in our stores.
In our stores, we differentiate ourselves by offering service amenities to customers, such as assisting a customer in locating a product by walking them over to the proper area and pointing it out to them, and not just saying “over on aisle 7″. We offer carry-out service to each customer, offering to carry their groceries purchases to their car, even though many decline. I can’t point to a metric that demonstrates the direct ROI of doing this, but we view them as value added services that are a part of a differentiated shopping experience. Offering these services is a part of our cultural DNA.
Social media has not yet reached the level of being part of our cultural DNA yet. Right now, it is a value added service that we offer to tech savvy customers that want engage with our brand. It will be interesting to see how it looks in a couple of years.
Gary Vaynerchuk: What’s the ROI of your mom?
Here’s another perspective on ROI from a social media guy who is a little more well known than me:
Related posts:
- You are always on stage with social media The social media spotlight A quick story about social media...
- This ain’t no social media Hogwarts, kids Learn about social media for HR from HR pros This...
- Why the Minnesota Nurses Association likes social media Nurses Union using social media successfully The Labor Relations Institute...
- Great sex and social media, it’s all about the response How to make your social media more responsive I’m sitting...
- Beyond Google alerts: social media brand management tools Monitoring your social media brand is crucial I talk a lot...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.






{ 41 comments… read them below or add one }
Fr Human Race Horse: One Definition of Social Media ROI:
Social Media ROI not always about the dollars
I’ve bee… http://t.co/2BM7955I
RT One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/eKZv6wLb @MikeVanDervort
on HRH: One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/HoyA900x #socialmedia #business #customer #facebook
One Definition of Social Media ROI: Social Media ROI not always about the dollars
I’ve been thinking about socia… http://t.co/WtqdMYUP
Love this via @MikeVanDervort: on HRH: One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/PAyAQD3F #socialmedia #business #customer #facebook
SocialMedia #ROI Not always about the dollars! http://t.co/WV0Mxybw Agree! I like the Return on Influence better!
RT #hrfl11 One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/ftvU2soF Stop and Read: #dthr
RT @mikevandervort: One definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/SzQr5DPT… #hr #shrm #dthr #tephr #hrevolution #in
RT #hrfl11 One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/ftvU2soF Stop and Read: #dthr
One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/Ja2xUcFB
I am interested what software you are using to measure the level of engagement from your fans? Are you doing any paid advertising to grow your user base? Thanks for the interesting perspective.
Twitter: MikeVanDervort
January 23, 2012 at 4:33 pm
Brendon, We use one of the major monitoring tools to listen to conversation, and we also get some metrics from our marketing agency that help to clarify engagement. We do use paid media in addition to organic and viral WOM to build our base. I can’t really be more specific than that. Thanks for commenting.
Great one from @mikevandervort >> Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/JC36VhtE
RT @thebuzzonhr: Great one from @MikeVanDervort >> Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/pj2YpMnf <thanks Buzz!
One definition of Social Media ROI #in http://t.co/RfUHk8ig
Another interesting take on #SocialMediaROI followed by the most impassioned video you'll see on the topic. #eValue http://t.co/p8JWgQVl
A new blog post (finally) Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/pj2YpMnf #hrfl12 #PRScamp #TNLIVE #hrhappyhour #tchat
RT @MikeVanDervort blog post (finally) SM ROI not always about dollars http://t.co/xLVqzPaV #hrfl12 #PRScamp #TNLIVE #hrhappyhour #tchat
AGREE, either is pricing @MeghanMBiro SM ROI not always about dollars http://t.co/tTFhxsS4 #prodmgmt
Great reflections on what @Publix gives/gets using social media > One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/pMObEVvN by @MikeVanDervort
A rather strong comment on: One definition of Social Media ROI (via #hr #shrm #dthr #tephr #hrevolution #some #in http://t.co/zbSeXUWz
RT @jennifermcclure: Gr8 reflections on what @Publix gives/gets using #sm > 1 Def. of #SocialMedia ROI: http://t.co/s7nsPNfv @MikeVanDervort
A new blog post (finally) Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/pj2YpMnf #hrfl12 #PRScamp #TNLIVE #hrhappyhour #tchat
Great reflections on what @Publix gives/gets using social media > One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/pMObEVvN by @MikeVanDervort
Great reflections on what @Publix gives/gets using social media > One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/pMObEVvN by @MikeVanDervort
One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/hEdGZgVf via @MikeVanDervort >> does the real value reside in the £££$$$
Twitter: bzzagent
January 24, 2012 at 10:28 am
Social media ROI is an important topic for marketers. BzzAgent has new data to show how effective social can be for CPG brands. We found that CPG marketers see an average of $1.50 for for every $1 spent in social marketing. Details at: http://www.bzzagent.com/blog/post/roi-social-marketing-150/
Twitter: MikeVanDervort
January 24, 2012 at 10:55 am
Thanks for sharing those numbers! Flattered that someone from dunhumby took at the post. You guys know what you are doing! – Michael
RT @MikeVanDervort: A new blog post (finally) Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/QDJUj8nW #hrfl12 #PRScamp
One definition of social media ROI from @MikeVanDervort. http://t.co/14ZMAo1f
RT @frankzupan: One definition of social media ROI from @MikeVanDervort. http://t.co/sZW6IQri #afterzupandaypartyglow
RT @MikeVanDervort: A new blog post (finally) Social Media ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/QDJUj8nW #hrfl12 #PRScamp
MT @sexythinker: RT @MikeVanDervort: New blog post #SocialMedia ROI not always about the dollars http://t.co/aF1WdiiL #hrfl12 #PRScamp #FSMU
Love this via @MikeVanDervort: One Definition of Social Media ROI http://t.co/XZZ8z8Qz #socialmedia #business #vistage #CEO #facebook
: One definition of social media ROI from @MikeVanDervort. http://t.co/sZW6IQri”. @socialfresh
Some #SoMe wisdom from @mikevandervort : One Definition of Social Media ROI: http://t.co/vm2cUjXB #PRSCamp
RT @FrankZupan: One definition of social media ROI from @MikeVanDervort. http://t.co/nwrdWXwm
One Definition of #socialmedia ROI – http://t.co/Gt50dYRQ
RT @perfectjulia: One Definition of #socialmedia #ROI – http://t.co/crHK2H65
Gary Vaynerchuk: What’s the #ROI of your mom? http://t.co/WGtDchua via @MikeVanDervort
Let's think youth development an nonprofits!! http://t.co/logCUfMI